Mon, May 21, 2012, 11:23 BST - UK Markets close in 5 hrs 7 mins

Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Are reusable nappies worth the effort?

    Will using cloth nappies on your bundle of joy save you a bundle of cash?

    6,000 nappies. That's the number of changes my infant son is likely to need between birth and potty training, according to official estimates. That's a figure to make any penny pincher gulp.

    Not only that, I also get a twinge of eco guilt every time I open my bin and see endless nappy bags ready to go to landfill.

    According to Go Real, a UK website supporting the use of washable nappies, new parents can kit their babies out for less than £80, if they use the cheapest option.

    Even factoring in £1 a week to cover the extra washing costs, it estimates parents can save upwards of £500 by using cloth nappies instead of disposables. That's a serious sum, so I've been wondering if it's time to change how I change my baby.

    [See also: Can dirty bed sheets save you money?]

    Green-minded mum

    I met Sarah, a north-west mum who uses washable nappies and even reusable baby wipes on her son. This is primarily to reduce what they send to landfill, but also to save some money.

    So how much has she spent getting set up in real nappies? "I would estimate that we have spent approximately £450 on nappies, wet bags, a nappy bucket, boosters, wraps and a few other related items. But it is possible to kit yourself out for much less… We spent more than we needed to as we wanted enough nappies not to have to do a wash every day."

    Aren't cloth nappies a huge amount of work? Sarah admitted they are more effort than disposables would be.

    "I usually wash a bucket full of nappies per day. Then I have to dry them. The microfibre ones come out of the washing machine almost dry but some varieties, such as those made from bamboo, need to be line or tumble dried… Finally, I have to 'build' the nappies. This entails 'stuffing' the pocket nappies and adding optional liners. So yes, they involve work but I still get pleasure from using them."

    Sarah's not using cheap Terry squares, so how much have her nappies cost? "The most I have spent on a single nappy was £17.50 and it leaked! My cheapest nappies cost £6.00 in [a] sale and work a treat."

    Washable vs disposable nappies

    Do the sums add up?

    If I bought nappies in small bags, they would cost around 22p each. Over 6,000 nappies, that would mean an eye-watering £1,320 in total.

    But I buy them in bulk, at a cost of around 10p each. So if my son goes through 6,000 nappies, it will cost me £600.

    Compare that to Sarah's £450 spend and it looks like cloth nappies win hands down. But the Go Real campaign reckons you'll spend about £1 a week washing them, including detergent and heating, adding at least another £104 to her costs.

    However, she can still save more than £46. After all, if they have more than one baby then she can reuse them again and, when she's done, there are many websites where you can sell second-hand cloth nappies.

    If you're considering washable nappies but are worried about the upfront cost, there are lots of council-run incentive schemes that can help.

    So there's certainly a compelling financial argument, but how much hassle are they?

    [See also: Potty training tips video]

    Are reusables usable?

    Environmentally-driven mums like Sarah may make cloth nappies look easy, but would they work for everyone? New parents spend half their lives washing baby clothes and pureeing carrots, is it really reasonable to expect them (read: me) to do more?

    I decided to try them out for myself and was sent samples from Dotty Bots, Baba+Boo and Millie's Nappies. They were very cute; I was expecting white towelling, not brightly coloured little fluffy shorts — my son looked like BamBam from The Flintstones.

    However, when I went to change him, his skin was wetter than if he'd been wearing a disposable — they don't seem to be as good at wicking away the moisture. I'd definitely be changing him more often if I used cloth nappies.

    Go Real estimates you need 15-24 nappies in total (most fit from birth to toddler) and will need to run a wash at least every three days. But Sarah washes more than that, so clearly it varies depending on how many your baby gets through.

    [See also: Can mums really have it all]

    So are reusable nappies worth the effort?

    Landfill isn't infinite or desirable, so it's obvious there's a compelling environmental case for switching to reusables.

    But they are undeniably quite a lot of extra work. You need to have a constant production line of washing, drying and stuffing if you're going to always have a dry nappy ready. That takes some serious organisation, which some sleep-starved parents may not be able to face.

    If you spend a few hundred quid on cloth nappies then your savings will be quite comparatively small, but if you use the cheaper Terry squares or buy them second hand then you could save a fortune over just one baby.

    Am I a convert? There's definitely a case for switching but I'll probably try to find a middle ground. If I use at least one cloth nappy a day then I can cut back on the financial and environmental cost without sacrificing the convenience.

    Felicity is Yahoo! Finance's money-saving columnist. If you have a money-saving scheme you'd like to see tried out then let us know in the comment box below.

    More money-saving features from Felicity

     
     
    Top Locations Bromley Nottingham

    175 comments

    • Sally  •  6 months ago
      GRRRRR!!! This article seems only to discuss expensive (£17!!!), and fiddly cloth nappies, and the difference in expense was marginal - my experience was much different. I bought a nappy kit, brand new, from an internet trader - it included 20 Motherease one-size nappies (which you can buy singly from Waitrose for about £8), 20 fleecy liners, 12 wraps (3 different sizes), a wet nappy bag, nappy bucket with lid, 20 cloth wipes, and a roll of disposable nappy liners all for £230.

      I used the nappies on both of my children saving even more money, and at one stage I had both children in washable nappies at the same time. When the kids were really small (they are now five, and three), I was probably washing every other day at most, but as they get older this drops to once a week as they wear less nappies. They did have a little nappy-rash occasionally, but that's also true of disposables sometimes. We used disposables when we went on holiday, but I found, although these were good at staying dry, they were a nightmare at keeping in a really runny poo - never had that problem with a washable. I would recommend washables to everyone, especially when you consider that EIGHT MILLION nappies A DAY are sent to landfill in Britain alone!
    • Sirius Bizniz  •  6 months ago
      Me and my siblings had a gauze like material for nappies in the 50s and 60s. They were simply laundered. I still have some which I use for dusting and wrapping crystal.
    • granny H  •  6 months ago
      You can make your own washable nappies,soaker pads and wipes from recycled garments such as cotton t shirts. I made loads for my daughters babies with a free pattern from the internet. You can also use wool or polar fleece pants instead of plastic. There are lots of knitting sewing and crochet pattens for these on the 'net too.
      It does not matter what colour the nappies are because you can cover them with clothing.
      • Shelley 6 months ago
        If you have enough time, I'm sure that's great!
    • Simon E  •  6 months ago
      Yet another superficial look at something. I use reusables and I would argue that they are no real extra work at all, about the same as folding a load of washing. I also got most of mine free from freecycle so have saved a small fortune.
    • Ro D  •  6 months ago
      What is wrong the terry towelling nappies used up to the late 60's or later. I used them on both my babies but I guess that washing nappies is too much like hard work for today's mothers. What looks better than a line full of white nappies blowing in the wind.....I got them nice and dry through the winter too. Piles of white bouncy terry nappies. Cost - used cigarette coupons, so cost nothing. (Green shield stamps, anyone?)
      • VELVET 6 months ago
        my mother bought 3 of us up on her own. she worked in a factory to keep a roof over our heads & then came home & had 3 children to feed, wash , etc. she had to keep the house clean & tidy, do the shopping, no car, no washing machine & no help. and you think you're hard done by with one baby. my god, you've got washing machines, driers, cars, and you cant cope because you're to tired. i've heard it all now. i hope you dont have no more, you might collapse!!!
      • VELVET 6 months ago
        its too much work for the mothers of today, they can barely cope with one child. washing, you'd never get them washing, its too much hard work, theyre too lazy
    • PHILIP  •  6 months ago
      What this survey hasn't taken in to account is that; If subsequent babies use the re-usable nappies then the cost is substantially less. I know that they have changed in style my 1 year old granddaughter is put in re-usables, but we are using the old fashioned Terry nappies as rags ( they were used on my children who now have kids of their own).
    • REBECCA  •  6 months ago
      Why the fear of washing? I love my son's fluffy little bamboo nappies and a 30 minute quick wash every day is really no bother. If doing it again I would buy some flat foldy squares for quicker drying. Sadly as I work he has to have disposables at nursery but there are biodegradable ones available at not much extra cost. Us mummies and daddies should be bringing our children up eco aware by showing good example.
      • silly guy 6 months ago
        get a wood burner in your home, then burn them. heat your home with the wee ones crap..
    • Elina  •  6 months ago
      £450 pounds? I spent about £120 only from birth to potty. Yes, I used my LA incentive scheme to buy 3 fold inserts (they look like a padded towel which you fold and tuck into waterproof covers). Got additional nappy covers second hand and used reusable fleece liners made from a fleece blanket from the £1 shop. Not a single nappy rash and 1-2 leaks in over 2 years. And guess what? When I was done with the nappies I gave away some to a friend with a new baby and sold the rest. I bet you can't do that with disposables! LOL
    • S  •  6 months ago
      Terry nappies are cheaper even factoring in washing costs because if you wash them and put them away you can reuse them for future children thereby reducing the cost. If you boil the nappies there is no need for any disinfectant. When I had my three the all used the same nappies and they where put in a bucket to soak then given a hard and long boil to make sure they where well and truly clean not only that but in summer when the weather is very warm you can lay them across the pram or cot so that they can cool down. When you have done with the children you can then use them as dusters hand towels for wahing the car and other such things
    • Andrea  •  6 months ago
      I used terry nappies with all five of my babies, which meant that given age differences I had two/three in nappies at any given time, a heck of a lot of nappies but one boil wash load a day done immediately after bath and bed time got everything back up to date by the morning. Yes you did have to be organised and have a routine but you need that anyway with babies and young children just to keep on top of all the clothing and bedding laundry, bath times, feeds, play time, story time and all the rest so one extra laod of washing a day is nothing. My only concession to disposables was for days out and holidays the cost of using them all the time would have put me in the bankrupcy court.
      • dennis 6 months ago
        Well done Andrea, it`s all about being organised . I was first to the nappy if needed as it`s a shared thing , 2 made them 2 look after them , good on you .
    • ELLIE  •  6 months ago
      I used washable nappies for my son and preferred them to disposables. I did not spend as much as the lady mentioned in this article - maybe about £200 on 2 sizes of nappy (not all at once) plus the occasional pack of flushable nappy liners. The liners kept my son's skin fairly dry and meant I could flush away the nasty stuff without having it filling my bin! I didn't have a tumble dryer at the time but they were a microfibre that was very quick drying and didn't make life too difficult. We used disposables if we were out for the day or overnight, but I was happy to put the washables back on, partly because they helped keep his trousers up! Now he is toilet trained and I have sold them 2nd hand, so that has helped too.
    • Gizmo  •  6 months ago
      I have a compromise of one disposable overnight for a dry sleep and Little Lamb Cotton & Bamboo Nappies for the rest of the time. I wash a load every other day after dinner, put them on the radiatior overnight and they are usually dry by the next day though I stagger the washes so I always have over a days worth (about 4/5) of nappies sitting ready to go (I have 20 nappies in total). I love them and in the summer when I pegged them out on the line they looked just lovely! Even with 2 adults, one baby, a dog and two cats my wheelie bin is usually only half full every monday on collection day! As for nappy rash my wee man has only had that whilst he was teething and even disposables made no difference during that time!
      • Anna 6 months ago
        Not as an advert but I use the same brand and I really like it!
    • Ken  •  6 months ago
      We have twins, and use terries. We tried out a few systems and terries are definitely easiest. They go in the machine last thing at night (about 20 per day), hung up in the morning. Where is the difficulty?

      The babies' skin can be a little wet when they come off, but they let us know when that is the case, and they don't sit around in a chemical drying agent. A bit of sudocrem keeps the rash at bay.

      I am constantly amazed that disposables still sell.
    • C.  •  6 months ago
      I hope you have fed, washed and brushed yourself and baby up. On parade, get yourselves down to the war memorial and pay respect for fallen men.
    • simon  •  6 months ago
      I would recommend them, I'm a dad and found them easy to use, stick them on the line in summer and the sun bleaches them, press stud fitting, a bit of conditioner and they always smell nice, and according to my wife (who's better at this sort of stuff) has saved us a bucket load of cash, some council's offer an incentive too (our's was £25) which doesn't sound like much, but it all helps!
      We're trying for a 2nd, and guess what....no nappy costs this time
    • Sarah  •  6 months ago
      I changed from disposables when my son was 1 because he was always getting nappy rash and after a trial of real nappies it disappeard and never came back! im using the same nappies on my 6 month old daughter now and she has never had nappy rash. I'm still sure i saved money even though we were a year using disposables esp when u take the wipes in to consideration.

      i spent around £450 on a set of nappies, washable baby wipes, wet bags etc and the nappies are still in great condition im sure they would do more babies (if i have any)! I have not even bought a packet of nappies or disposable baby wipes since i started using washable ones, there is always a nice warm tap nearby (much nicer than cold wipes) and i have a water spray if im caught out - I have different colour wipes for face and bum, bum ones go in with nappies and face in our normal wash! I dont even buy liners as use fleece ones which are easy to rinse if soiled with runny poo (otherwise it just drops off down the toilet) and they are nicer on babys bum.

      Really once you establish using them its so easy and many local councils do incentives such as vouchers, trial packs or nappy lending kits its worth looking into as its a lot of money to spend if it doesnt work out.

      also its not about soaking, rinsing, dangerous pins and nappy san, you just need to break them down put them in a 60 wash and put them back together again (which you can do in front of the telly).

      not fogetting my nice clean wheelie bin which was always overflowing and stinking before,

      i also think its good for my washing machine pipes to go on a hot wash now again (thats just me tho),

      my nursery and any other child carers found them no bother to use as they are fitted - i just get them back at night ready to break down into the nappy bin!

      i found most of this out myself by using them but now im always happy to share my love of real nappies to anyone who will listen

      I could go on and on...
    • shooo!  •  6 months ago
      A real mother only needs:-----1). A sink to wash soiled nappies. 2). Elbow grease. (in short supply, these days). 3). Zinc and Castor oil. 4). A kiss and cuddle for baby, and repeat. Worked for me.
    • SARAH  •  6 months ago
      I used washables for my son - leant to me by a friend. Cost NOTHING! When he was potty trained I passed them on to the next family. Washing is only a problem if you are a prissy princess.
    • Sarah  •  6 months ago
      We use cloth nappies during the day and disposables at night.... There is a little extra effort, but it's not that bad at all... I'm really glad that we switched to cloth... I'm surprise her babies bum was wet when she changed his nappies, our little girls isn't, we do use fleece liners to protect her bum, so maybe that's why... I would most definitely choose cloth over disposables any day...
      x
    • ryoko  •  6 months ago
      When I had my son I looked into all of this purely with an idea to save cash and realised all the stuff about it being cheaper was rubbish, it's only cheaper if you buy the cheapest washable ones you can find vs the most expensive branded disposible nappies. the washable nappies are extremely expensive, you have to pay even more for a one size for all, or just keep buying new ones when they grow out of it, I was advised you need to have at least 12 on the go, so if you don't buy the one size fits all ones (cheapest I've seen them is £24 each) thats at least 33 nappies you have to buy that are £6+ but at that price it's just the pants you still need to buy the pads, cheapest of course are the terry ones, but then you need the washable pad and if you want the non-eco plastic liners to stop leaks.

      In the end I asked my mother about it all who is old enough to have had children before the introduction of the disposible ones, there are good reasons why people turned to them, it wasn't just the ease not having to wash them and scrap the poo off em, they leak less, smell less and your child is many times less likely to get nappy rash and for want of a better word poo explosions.

      My son is now 18 months old and I still have over half a tub of nappy rash cream I bought before he was born, plus I buy non-brand nappies that work out to around 10p each.

      Plus I throw away many plastic tubs and things that can not be recycled in my area, I still use disposible sanitary towels, disposible razors, I don't drive but I've seen people get in their cars just to go to the letter box, I use many household chemical cleaners and the like, to subject my son to a less hygienic nappy that costs more to do my bit for eco friendliness just seems a bit pointless in the great scheme of things.