Yahoo Finance What 227 Y Combinator pitches will teach you about startups
Welcome to Startups Weekly, a fresh human-first take on this week’s startup news and trends. To get this in your inbox, subscribe here.
In some ways, Y Combinator’s biannual Demo Day is somewhat predictable: There will be Stanford dropouts, last-minute pivots, and, as always, promises of near-term profitability. We even made a bingo board about it.
But one thing I can never guess ahead of time is the exact priorities of the season’s batch. Y Combinator stands by the fact that it backs people, not ideas, so its Demo Day technically unveils two things: who the accelerator bet on and what they decided to prioritize. This year was different for myriad reasons. First, YC Summer 2022 is the second batch to receive a $500,000 check instead of $125,000, as part of the accelerator’s expanded check size. Second, the batch was smaller than usual (see previous versions of this column here and here; it’s a different tone altogether) — a narrowing of focus the accelerator says was due to the downturn. And finally, it was the first batch where we saw a bifurcation; over 60% of batch founders were in the Bay Area during the three-month accelerator, while others remained scattered across the world.
All those tensions are great for story ideas. So, this week when covering YC’s latest batch, we set out to give readers a better understanding of the problems that startups are prioritizing during the downturn and how YC’s shake-up has impacted the firm’s focus in certain areas and geographies versus others.
I’m proud of how we executed despite all the iPhone news. We wrote about how YC’s fintech founders are returning to the neobank train and crypto continues to be an area of bullishness. We dug into artificial intelligence standouts and creator economy knockouts. And before I start sounding like an especially nerdy rendition of Dr. Seuss, we looked into a geography focus from a macro scale and a retreat on a micro scale.
This in mind, as in tradition, I want to leave you with a few takeaways I had after listening to hundreds of pitches. Here’s what 277 Combinator pitches taught me, and now maybe you, about startups:
Ideas, then people or people then ideas: There’s two camps of investing in startups, the check writers who invest in disruptive ideas and then the various groups of people trying to make those same ideas a reality; and the check writers who invest in people and then support those same people in whatever disruptive idea they swing at. Y Combinator asserts that it's more of the latter not the former. But, data says differently. Last batch, 29% were accepted with only an idea; this batch, 43% were accepted with only an idea. It means that over time, YC is getting more comfortable backing founders who have an idea; not necessarily less. Something to think about when looking at trends and how one of the most well-known accelerators thinks about breakdowns.
A common investing trap:
Investing in a startup because its a dope idea or a business that should exist
Most businesses that are "good ideas" will have lots of teams competing to win, and your job is to back the winning team
YC alone is now backing many teams per good idea!
— Ankur Nagpal 🔥🔥 (@ankurnagpal) September 7, 2022
It’s a fintech accelerator, first: Whoops, my bias is showing. YC feels more and more like a fintech and crypto accelerator than it does a consumer and biotech accelerator; you can tell that based on the breakdown of startups within each batch but even from the format of Demo Day. It’s hard to tell a biotech or climate story with one slide in one minute while the format actually helps a startup trying to make financial services easier.
The moonshots aren’t going anywhere: One theory I had going into the batch is if bigger checks, even despite a downturn, will lead to bigger swings in the batch. We weren’t disappointed. Moonshots include faux fish, alternative investing in athletes and another ambitious play in the world of DTC healthcare.
In this week’s digest, we’ll get into some startup consolidation, Kim Kardashian and the latest on layoffs. Make sure to read the whole piece as I’ve snuck in a TC+ discount code, especially for Startups Weekly readers, in the post.
If you like this newsletter, do me a quick favor? Forward it to a friend, share it on Twitter and tag me so I can thank you for reading myself!
Startups, get scooped
We don’t talk about liquidity enough here, and I partially blame the fact that the M&A market has felt quite dry over the past few months. Thankfully, we have a few of note to mention this week.
Amazon bought Cloosertermans, a mechatronics specialist that will help it beef up its robotics arm. TC’s Ingrid Lunden reports that the startup has been ”building technology to move and stack heavy palettes and totes, and robotics used to package products for customer orders.” The attention from Amazon isn’t new: Amazon has been a Cloostermans customer since 2019, but the acquisition makes things a lot more formal.
There’s also an acquisition from Instacart, which has been busy ahead of its impending public market debut. The grocery delivery company announced that it acquired Rosie. It will widen the company’s footprint for local and independent retailers.
And, to end the week, we have online grocery company Misfits Market announcing it will acquire Imperfect Foods. I love when Misfits and Imperfects team together.
Here’s why it’s important: More consolidation gives us some much-needed signals on how the exit environment is doing these days. For early-stage startups, especially those that are struggling to raise another round, the future could look like becoming acquisition fodder (and that’s not bad news).
Image Credits: Caiaimage/Adam Gault / Getty Images
VC works hard, but Kim Kardashian works harder
Kim Kardashian announced this week that she is breaking into the private equity world with SKKY Partners. Her firm, done in collaboration with ex-Carlyle partner Jay Sammons, has not yet raised its first fund but does plan to make its first investment by the end of the year.
Here’s what's important: It’s the financialization of trendsetters, as we discussed on Equity. We've seen influencers land partnerships, start companies, score equity in startups, but PE would be a different level — even for a Kardashian.
Image Credits: Nathan Congleton/NBC / Getty Images
The follow-up
I’m experimenting with a new section in Startups Weekly, where each week we follow up with an old story or trend to see what’s changed since our first look. We haven’t talked about layoffs in a bit around here, so without further ado…
Here’s what’s new: Patreon has confirmed it has laid off five employees from its security team. It will lean on external organizations to develop security capabilities. There’s also some tensions leaking out of Aurora while Nigerian digital bank Kuda is the latest African startup to lay off employees.
Image Credits: Patreon
THE TECHCRUNCH DISRUPT 2022 AGENDA IS OUT.
Wait for it. See it? Yep, I’m excited too. And while we’re on the topic of housekeeping, some more notes:
Listen to TechCrunch’s other podcasts, including our crypto-focused show that goes by Chain Reaction and founder-focused show that goes by Found. The TechCrunch Podcast also continues to entertain the heck out of me, so pay attention to all the good shows that they’re putting out.
Remember that TechCrunch Live is on a brand new platform, and we've made it easier to apply for pitch practice. Investors (and my inbox) can attest to the importance of brevity, savviness and clarity in pitches so it’s great to see. Startups can now apply any day, any time for Pitch Practice by completing this form.
Go mining for opportunity at TC Sessions: Crypto this November in Miami. Yep, you heard it right, we’re making it to Miami.
Seen on TechCrunch
As a scuba diver, I would gladly trust my life to the Apple Watch. Here’s why.
Brex’s departing CRO explains his decision to join Founders Fund
People are going back to the office — except in the Bay Area
Byju’s has no answer for its growing list of missing deadlines
YC Demo Day did not have a very long list of creator companies, but here’s who stood out
To thank you for being a Startups Weekly subscriber, here’s a little TC+ discount for you: Enter “STARTUPS” at checkout for 15% off of your subscription.
Seen on TechCrunch+
These are the top 3 most important slides in your pitch deck
How the upcoming Ethereum Merge could change crypto’s rewards, costs and reputation
Let’s get in the weeds about fintech AUM
As startups whip up a restaurant tech frenzy, is anyone close to Toast?
Can you believe it was technically a short week? Chat Monday.
