UK Markets closed

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

·10-min read

- By

Stocks which are paying unusually high dividends are a bit scary because unusually high dividends typically mean the stock price has declined and the market does not believe that the payout is worth it.

To take a high dividend payer seriously, I look to see what else is going on. Is the chef eating his own cooking? As renowned investor Peter Lynch used to say, "Insiders might sell their shares for any number of reasons, but they buy them for only one, they think the price will rise."


While insiders don't always buy because they think the stock price will go up, that is the most common reason, so insider buying definitely means a stock could be worth a closer look. Thus, using the GuruFocus All-in-One screener, I looked for stocks with high dividends and substantial recent insider buys. Among the results, I selected the following five candidates for further exploration.

OneMain Holdings

OneMain Holdings Inc. (NYSE:OMF) is one of the largest non-prime consumer finance companies in the United States and one of only a few companies in the consumer installment lending industry. Its services include providing personal plans, credit and non-credit insurance, servicing loans, pursuing strategic acquisitions and dispositions of assets and businesses, and on occasion, establishing joint ventures or forming strategic alliances. In addition to hundreds of branches, the company also has a significant online business. Its main source of revenue is net interest income.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

The dividend yield is impressive at over 10%.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Douglas Shulman, the President and CEO, recently spent about quarter of million dollars buying shares.

Insider

Position

Date

Buy/Sell

Shares

Shares Owned

Trade Price($)

Cost($1000)

Price change since trade(%)

Share ownership details

Apollo Management Holdings GP,

10% Owner

2021-08-16

Sell

8,050,000

17,562,500

56.72

456,596

+0.23

See footnote(F1,):17,562,500

Shulman Douglas H.

President and CEO

2021-08-06

Buy

8,575

245,313

58.32

500.09

-2.52

245,313 (Direct)

Apollo Management Holdings GP,

10% Owner

2021-08-03

Sell

10,925,000

25,612,500

58.36

637,583

-2.57

See Footnote(F1,):25,612,500


Apollo Management, a private equity giant which owns about 22% of the company, looks like it's in the process of cashing out. Miller Value Partners (Trades, Portfolio), a noted value investor, also owns this stock.

Given the above factors, I believe OneMain is worth looking at in more detail. These personal finance companies do very well when the economy is booming, but risk may show up when the government stimulus ends or if the economy begins to slow down. The CEO is certainly putting his money where his mouth is.

Universal Health Realty Income Trust

Universal Health Realty Income Trust (NYSE:UHT) is a health care real estate investment trust with a property portfolio spanning hospitals, acute care hospitals, rehabilitation hospitals, free-standing emergency departments, sub-acute facilities, medical office buildings and child care centers. Over half of the firm's properties are located in Arizona, Nevada and Texas.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

In theory, this company should be recession-resistant. After shooting up in the past couple years, the stock seems to have come down to earth.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Insiders seem to be taking advantage of the low prices with CEO Alan Miller recently spending over a quarter of a million dollars to buy 4,500 shares, taking his share count up to 176,655.

Insider

Position

Date

Buy/Sell

Shares

Shares Owned

Trade Price($)

Cost($1000)

Price change since trade(%)

Share ownership details

MILLER ALAN B

President, and CEO

2021-08-17

Buy

4,500

176,655

57.16

257.22

+1.31

134,655 (Direct)

By The Alan B. Miller Family Foundation:42,000


The dividend yield is 4.8%. The payout ratio is high, but that is not out of line for a triple net REIT.

Dividend Yield %

4.8

Dividend Payout Ratio

1.71

3-Year Dividend Growth Rate

1.5

Forward Dividend Yield %

4.84


The key metrics to track for REITs include Operating Cash Flow (OCF) and Funds from Operations (FFO) per share, and both metrics seem to be doing well, indicating dividend sustainability. Universal Health has been paying out a steadily rising dividend for 35 years.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Golub Capital BDC

Golub Capital BDC Inc. (NASDAQ:GBDC) is a closed-end investment company. Its investment objective is to generate current income and capital appreciation by investing in senior secured and one-stop loans in United States middle-market companies. It also invests in the second lien and subordinated loans, warrants and minority equity securities. The company generally invests in securities that have been rated below investment grade by independent rating agencies or that would be rated below investment grade if they were rated.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Golub got hit hard during the start of the 2020 Covid-19 crisis but now has mostly recovered.

The company's shares have been heavily bought by both the Chairman and the CEO. Between the two, they own about 8.7 million shares, or over 5% of the company.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Insider

Position

Date

Buy/Sell

Shares

Shares Owned

Trade Price($)

Cost($1000)

Price change since trade(%)

Share ownership details

Golub Lawrence E

Chairman

2021-08-12

Buy

5,059

4,506,251.12

15.81

79.98

-0.06

By GGP Holdings, L.P.:2,427,547.062

By Whitehall Capital Investors N, LLC:430,177

By Polar Madison Holdings, LLC:274,518

By Golub Onshore GP, LLC:14,977.824

By GCOP LLC:1,359,031.232

Golub David

CEO

2021-08-12

Buy

5,059

4,282,293.07

15.81

79.98

-0.06

125,388.954 (Direct)

By GGP Holdings, L.P.:2,427,547.062

By CDGPE, LLC:188,676

By CDGQ, LLC:166,672

By Golub Onshore GP LLC:14,977.824

By GCOP LLC:1,359,031.232


Golub pays a 7.34% dividend with a decently low payout ratio.

Dividend Yield %

7.34

Dividend Payout Ratio

0.52

3-Year Dividend Growth Rate

-0.2


Golub's stock is trading close to tangible book value and the graham number.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

It is important to note that business development companies (BDC's) like Golub are inherently risky as they loan out money to smaller companies and their performance will depend largely on how the main street economy will do in the next few years. In the 2007-2009 recession, many BDC's went out of business. I consider them a good portfolio diversifier but certainly wouldn't depend on the income.

FS KKR Capital Corp (NYSE:FSK)

Like Golub, FS KKR Capital Corp is also a business development company based in the United States. It caters to middle market companies. It is also engaged in investing in senior secured debt and, to a lesser extent, the subordinated debt of private middle market U.S. companies.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

It also took a big hit last year and has mostly recovered to pre-pandemic levels.

It pays a sweet 10.35% dividend yield.

Dividend Yield %

10.35

Dividend Payout Ratio

0.23

3-Year Dividend Growth Rate

-9.3

Forward Dividend Yield %

11.22

5-Year Yield-on-Cost %

7.52


Insiders have been quite active buying shares in the last few months, which could indicate a potential opportunity.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Insider

Position

Date

Buy/Sell

Shares

Shares Owned

Trade Price($)

Cost($1000)

Price change since trade(%)

Share ownership details

Hopkins Jerel A

Director

2021-09-01

Buy

840

4,000.85

23.15

19.45

+0.13

4,000.846 (Direct)

Sandler Elizabeth

Director

2021-08-30

Buy

1,250

2,140

22.95

28.69

+1

2,140 (Direct)

Gerson Brian

Co-President

2021-08-26

Buy

5,000

5,000

22.95

114.75

+1

5,000 (Direct)

KROPP JAMES H

Director

2021-08-18

Buy

1,000

13,477.16

22.78

22.78

+1.76

IRA:13,477.158

Goebel William Balke

Chief Accounting Officer

2021-08-18

Buy

1,100

4,458.56

22.92

25.21

+1.13

4,458.556 (Direct)

Forman Michael C.

CEO

2021-08-17

Buy

10,000

379,802.34

22.98

229.80

+0.87

In IRA account:13,119.081

By MCFDA SCV LLC:124,551.246

By FSH Seed Capital Vehicle I LLC:231,152

By Spouse:5,134.249

By Trust FBO Minor Children:1,290.654

In 401(k) account:4,555.11

Goldstein Richard I

Director

2021-08-17

Buy

1,237

24,000.22

22.98

28.43

+0.87

IRA:24,000.223

Sypherd Stephen

VP & Secretary

2021-08-16

Buy

2,500

9,623.89

22.99

57.48

+0.83

9,623.894 (Direct)

Builione Todd C.

Director

2021-08-13

Buy

5,000

8,125

23.11

115.55

+0.30

8,125 (Direct)

Ford Brian R.

Director

2021-08-12

Buy

1,731

7,776.67

22.72

39.33

+2.02

7,776.667 (Direct)

Pietrzak Daniel

Co-President and CIO

2021-08-12

Buy

5,000

17,500

22.73

113.65

+1.98

7,500 (Direct)

IRA:10,000

Goldstein Richard I

Director

2021-08-11

Buy

1,000

22,763.22

22.64

22.64

+2.39

IRA:22,763.223

Adams Barbara

Director

2021-08-11

Buy

3,214

9,939

22.74

73.09

+1.93

1,943 (Direct)

IRA:7,996

IMASOGIE OSAGIE O

Director

2021-08-11

Buy

39,825

48,488

22.74

905.62

+1.93

48,488 (Direct)


NGL Energy Partners LP

NGL Energy Partners LP (NYSE:NGL) is a U.S.-based publicly traded midstream Master Limited Partnership (MLP) that owns and operates a vertically integrated energy business. The company's operating segments include Crude Oil Logistics, Water Solutions and Liquids Logistics. It operates crude oil storage terminals, owns pipeline injection stations and offers services for the treatment and disposal of wastewater generated from crude oil and natural gas production. The firm also supplies natural gas liquids, propane and distillates to retailers, wholesalers, refiners and petrochemical plants.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

The company's stock peaked in 2014 and has been declining continually ever since.

The company is paying out a mind-boggling dividend distribution of 16.85%.

Dividend Yield %

16.85

3-Year Dividend Growth Rate

-31.6

5-Year Yield-on-Cost %

5.28

3-Year Average Share Buyback Ratio

-2.2


The company's business seems to be recovering based on the below chart, and Free Cash Flow has moved into the green.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Insiders have been snapping up the stock recently.

5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge
5 High Dividend Stocks With an Insider Edge

Insider

Position

Date

Buy/Sell

Shares

Shares Owned

Trade Price($)

Cost($1000)

Price change since trade(%)

Share ownership details

KRIMBILL H MICHAEL

CEO

2021-08-27

Buy

200,000

2,392,170

1.50

300

+18.67

2,028,615 (Direct)

SEE FTN:363,555

COLLINGSWORTH JAMES M

Director

2021-08-26

Buy

25,000

335,870

1.49

37.25

+19.46

325,500 (Direct)

SEE FOOTNOTE(F3,):9,500

SEE FOOTNOTE(F4,):870

Ciolek John

Executive Vice President

2021-08-17

Buy

10,000

252,264

1.40

14

+27.14

252,264 (Direct)

KRIMBILL H MICHAEL

CEO

2021-08-13

Buy

200,000

2,192,170

1.52

304

+17.11

1,828,615 (Direct)

SEE FTN:363,555

KRIMBILL H MICHAEL

CEO

2021-08-12

Buy

150,000

1,992,170

1.55

232.50

+14.84

1,628,615 (Direct)

SEE FTN:363,555

Ciolek John

Executive Vice President

2020-06-05

Buy

10,000

75,733

6.97

69.70

-74.46

75,733 (Direct)

COLLINGSWORTH JAMES M

Director

2020-03-12

Buy

25,000

10,370

3

75

-40.65

870 (Direct)

See Footnote(F2,):9,500

KRIMBILL H MICHAEL

CEO

2020-03-06

Buy

25,000

1,625,433

6.35

158.75

-71.95

1,261,878 (Direct)

SEE FTN:363,555

Karlovich Robert W III

CFO, Exec VP

2020-03-06

Buy

10,000

125,382

6.49

64.90

-72.57

125,382 (Direct)


Conclusion

The companies listed above could be worthwhile to look into as potential investment opportunities, in my opinion. The two BDC's are cyclical and risky but are paying out big dividends. The finance company and the health care REIT appear to be of medium and low risk, respectively. The midstream company is speculative, but oil prices are recovering, so this could be a multi-bagger.

This article first appeared on GuruFocus.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting