Anstead shared a snapshot of the actor's eye-catching birthday cake, which featured a shirtless photo of Marsden from his modeling days
In honor of the actor’s 50th birthday on Monday, Anstead, 44, shared a snapshot of Marsden’s birthday cake, which included a shirtless black and white photo of him from his modeling days, and praised his youthful looks.
“So great celebrating @james_marsden 50th! I swear this dude is aging backwards!” Anstead captioned the Instagram Story.
At the bash, Marsden was presented with the white-frosted cake, which also featured black piping and gold candles, including the numbers 5 and 0.
“Happy 50th Birthday JAMES!” was also written in black icing at the bottom of the dessert.
Guests were treated to Shake Shack burgers with personalized stickers on the wrappers, reading, “Marsden is 50,” as well as a cocktail menu.
“James’ Birthday Cocktails” list offered up a cucumber jalapeño margarita, a passion fruit margarita and casa ranch water.
After the party, Marsden took to his Instagram Story on Monday to thank Casamigos for throwing the bash.
“A huge thank you to @casamigos and @rachelzaliz for keeping the party going strong and the drinks flowing late,” he wrote alongside a picture of him holding a drink at the venue’s bar.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
The vehicle was a surprise gift for Marsden’s brother-in-law, but as he, Anstead and Anstead’s co-host Cristy Lee set about dismantling the car, Marsden admitted in a confessional that the task “seemed a lot easier in my head."
"I'm having a blast, we're going here taking the whole car apart," he said, adding, “It is my first time to really get that deep into, you know, disassembling a car."
— Ant Anstead (@AntAnstead) November 2, 2021
Later that year, Anstead also shared a post on X about attending an automotive exhibition with Marsden in November.
"Hitting the @SEMASHOW with the James Marsden @Buick from #CelebrityIOUJoyride," he wrote alongside a smiling selfie of himself and Marsden, the restored car and the pair hanging out with former Formula 1 driver Jenson Button.
For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!
Read the original article on People.