A government claim that the new UK-Japan trade agreement will lead to cheaper soy sauce has been shot down as it was pointed out that Britain pays 0% tariffs under an EU deal.
The Department for International Trade (DIT) made the claim in a tweet during Tuesday night’s broadcast of The Great British Bake Off, where it was Japanese week and the bakers made kawaii cakes.
The bakers used a lot of soya sauce in the first challenge on #GBBO, so it's a good thing it will be made cheaper thanks to our trade deal with Japan 🇯🇵
— Department for International Trade (@tradegovuk) October 27, 2020
The trade secretary, Liz Truss, keen to promote the benefits of the much-heralded post-Brexit deal with Japan, retweeted the post.
Loved the Kawaii bakes! So much shared culture between 🇬🇧🇯🇵. #GBBO
— Liz Truss (@trussliz) October 27, 2020
But it was pointed out that the tariff on soy sauce from Japan is already 0% thanks to a free trade agreement between Tokyo and the EU.
We already have a zero-tariff deal with Japan via the EU, oh and the UK imports a lot of its soy(a) sauce through the Netherlands where, come 1 Jan, the likely lengthy delays and additional paperwork will probably *add* cost to the consumer. Otherwise great stuff, Liz! https://t.co/EPdnTduWZc
— Seb Dance 🌹🇪🇺 (@SebDance) October 27, 2020
David Henig, a trade expert, wrote: “Current tariff on soy sauce entering the UK from Japan – 0%. Tariff on soy sauce entering UK after UK-Japan trade deal – 0%. Not a good look when you can’t trust a government social media account to tell the truth.”
Others noted that the UK imports relatively little of its soy sauce from Japan.
The most popular soya sauce brand in the UK is manufactured in the Netherlands with ingredients not from Japan... pic.twitter.com/V4gDFP4e25
— Dean Hochlaf (@Dhochlaf) October 27, 2020
The popular Kikkoman brand is manufactured in the Netherlands and is currently imported free of any duty. The tariff will rise to 6% by default if no trade deal is agreed with the EU before the end of the Brexit transition period at the end of the year.
Other popular brands are made in Wales, as the Welsh MP Anna McMorrin pointed out along with hundreds of others.
— Anna McMorrin MP 🏴🇪🇺😷🏳️🌈 (@AnnaMcMorrin) October 27, 2020
DIT appeared to compound its own goal by adding later that “under WTO terms, the tariff on soya [sic] sauce is 6%. Under our deal, they will be 0%”.
The UK does not trade under WTO terms with Japan and would default to a tariff system that would closely follow the EU tariff regime if it crashes out of the bloc without a deal.
A DIT spokesperson said: “Currently the UK global tariff on soya sauce is 6%, therefore if we had not secured a UK-Japan trade deal, soya sauce would cost consumers more come the 1 January 2021.”