Sean Gallagher/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty
Drew Barrymore's recent pumpkin picking trip with her daughters didn't quite go as she planned.
During her appearance Tuesday on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, the 46-year-old actress shared the story of the "Halloween miracle" that occurred when she was recently leaving the pumpkin patch with her two daughters Olive, 9, and Frankie, 7.
The 50 First Dates star explains that she was trying to teach daughter Olive a "life lesson" after she picked out a giant pumpkin that they wouldn't be able to carry to the checkout.
"I had this whole life lesson with Olive about letting it go, we couldn't carry it, like make your peace with it and she really did," she recalls. "Then we got to the checkout stand and this guy wheelbarrowed it up and we both started crying."
"She had learned to love and let go and then I started crying and then we were like, 'It's a Halloween miracle!' " Barrymore tells host Jimmy Fallon. "Then he had this beautiful Jesus around his neck and I started having a religious moment."
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
After the man brought over Olive's pumpkin, Barrymore says as a parent she "started spiraling" as this wasn't the lesson she intended to teach her daughter, whom she shares with ex Will Kopelman.
"This isn't the lesson, the lesson was let it go, not you get it," she says. "So I'm like paralyzed as a parent like not knowing how to handle this situation. I want to make it okay for him and I want her to learn her lesson."
The daytime talk show host says she tried to pay the man for the pumpkin or get his phone number to thank him but he "wanted nothing."
"Then we carved it and we saved all the seeds and we had this whole ceremony and I said, 'We can't send him a picture and he didn't want anything in return, because he's a saint, clearly,' " she says. "But if he ever hears this story, you really made me and my daughter cry and the pumpkin is beautiful and it did make us believe in miracles."