"I honestly always thought my Masters in fine arts would get me further in the acting world than knowing how to work an espresso machine," he said in 2018. "That was a happy accident and I'm very, very grateful to have had that skill."
When Tyler booked the role on Friends, he was working at The Bourgeois Pig in Hollywood. He remained an employee at the coffee shop for several years, even while appearing on the hit show.
For more on James Michael Tyler and other top stories, listen below to our daily podcast PEOPLE Every Day.
"I kept my job at The Bourgeois Pig for the next four years. So I kept my day job, in other words, because I never knew if they were going to bring me back," he told BuzzFeed News in 2014.
"But once Gunther was more established and they would have me on all week, not just one day a week, basically, I thought, okay, I don't really have time for this. The Bourgeois Pig managers and owners said, 'Honestly, you're only here like one or two shifts,' and there were other employees who were friends of mine," he continued. "I loved it for the social aspect — it was like my way to see everybody in the neighborhood — but I'm like, I really should give these shifts up. Because it just didn't seem right."
Warner Bros. /Everett James Michael Tyler on Friends
And even though his espresso machine knowledge got him the part, Tyler never actually had to make a beverage on set.
"The espresso machine wasn't plugged in because they can be kind of loud," he revealed. "But that was a real antique coffee machine. I never actually made one coffee!"
While he wasn't a primary cast member, Tyler was included in a 2019 LEGO Friends set. It featured the show's iconic Central Perk coffee shop, where Tyler's character was employed.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Anthony Harvey/Getty James Michael Tyler
Tyler died following his battle with stage 4 prostate cancer. He first disclosed his diagnosis in June, approximately three years after he began treatment in 2018.
Tyler said his health struggles were what kept him from making an in-person appearance at the HBO Max Friends reunion special, which aired in May.
"I wanted to be a part of that, and initially I was going to be on the stage, at least, with them, and be able to take part in all the festivities," he said on the Today show in June. "It was bittersweet, honestly. I was very happy to be included. It was my decision not to be a part of that physically and make an appearance on Zoom, basically, because I didn't wanna bring a downer on it, you know?"