'Apologies don't bring back our children': Pope's presence draws mixed reaction, calls to rescind Doctrine of Discovery
As Pope Francis began his mass on Thursday at Sainte-Anne-de-Beaupré Basilica in Quebec, protesters called on him to further his reconciliation efforts.
Protesters held up a sign that read "rescind the doctrine," in reference to the Doctrine of Discovery, papal edicts dating back to the 15th century that led to colonization and seizure of Indigenous land.
Today too, there are any number of forms of ideological colonization that become open to the “cancel culture” that neglects their duties toward the most weak and vulnerable: the poor, migrants, the elderly, the sick, the unborn… They are the forgotten ones in well-off societies.
— Pope Francis (@Pontifex) July 28, 2022
"With heartfelt sorrow on its difficult and demanding journey of healing and reconciliation, and confronting the scandal of evil and the body of Christ wounded in the flesh of our Indigenous brothers and sisters, we too have experienced deep dismay," the Pope said. "We too feel the burden of failure."
Former Manitoba senator Murray Sinclair and chair of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, issued a statement on Tuesday following the Pope's apology, stating that Pope Francis has "left a deep hole in the acknowledgement of the full role of the Church in the Residential School system, by placing blame on individual members of the Church."
"It is important to underscore that the Church was not just an agent of the state, nor simply a participant in government policy, but was a lead co-author of the darkest chapters in the history of this land," the statement reads. "Driven by the Doctrine of Discovery and other Church beliefs and doctrines, Catholic leaders not only enabled the Government of Canada, but pushed it even further in its work to commit cultural genocide of Indigenous peoples."
While an apology has been made, that same doctrine is in place. The Pope and the Church remain silent on the most problematic tenets of its belief system: that Indigenous peoples in Canada and around the world should not have the right to practice their own faith, cultures, and traditions. Reconciliation requires action, not passiveness.
Canadians continue to take to social media to respond to the Pope's continued presence in Canada this week.
While Pope Francis is holding a mass at St. Anne du Beaupre, Quebec, outside is a sign that our peoples spirit lives! pic.twitter.com/0N9ZA6y2Dj
— Russ Diabo (@RussDiabo) July 28, 2022
The Pope & Catholic Church must officially, fully & by whatever legal & religious means necessary, rescind, repeal, revoke, withdraw & publicly condemn genocidal #DoctrineOfDiscovery & take whatever actions necessary to make reparations for harms caused #Indigenous #papalvisit https://t.co/nZ2NKIl3J3
— Pam Palmater (@Pam_Palmater) July 25, 2022
To be clear, we have to be okay with people’s disappointment, rage, and sadness just as much as we do the happiness.
That the apology fell short is NOT something people have to be okay with. https://t.co/vMBpNkigkz— Ri / ᕒᐊᔦᓬᐄ (@Rileyyesnomaybe) July 27, 2022
It isn’t solely #IRS survivors for whom Vatican c/o @Pontifex must apologize to But All Indigenous ppls due to the #genocide ideology rooted in #DoctrineOfDiscovery of the Catholic Church, Carried out by European & states of the Americas: Vatican must accept their culpability
— Ellen Gabriel (@EllenGabriel1) July 25, 2022
Reminder: Indigenous people are diverse. There are many different ways that we are responding to the Papal visit - anger, sadness, gratitude, hope, frustration. These are all valid responses.
— Dr. Kisha Supernant (she/her) (@ArchaeoMapper) July 25, 2022
My response? Mostly indifference. Apologies don't bring back our children or help us revitalize our culture.
— Dr. Kisha Supernant (she/her) (@ArchaeoMapper) July 25, 2022
No apology?
- No admission that the Holy See leadership failed to stop this?
- No return of stolen sacred items?
- No reparations?
- No rescission of the Papal Donations of 1493, source of the #DoctrineOfDiscovery?
No forgiveness earned!https://t.co/wAEKGRVNWW— Breen Ouellette (he/him) (@BreenOuellette) July 28, 2022