Q4 2023 Penske Automotive Group Inc Earnings Call

Participants

Anthony R. Pordon; Executive VP of IR & Corporate Development; Penske Automotive Group, Inc.

Michelle Hulgrave; Executive VP & CFO; Penske Automotive Group, Inc.

Randall Seymore; COO of International Operations; Penske Automotive Group, Inc.

Richard P. Shearing; COO of North American Operations; Penske Automotive Group, Inc.

Roger S. Penske; Chairman & CEO; Penske Automotive Group, Inc.

Daniel Robert Imbro; MD & Research Analyst; Stephens Inc., Research Division

David Whiston; Sector Strategist; Morningstar Inc., Research Division

John Joseph Murphy; MD and Lead United States Auto Analyst; BofA Securities, Research Division

Michael Ward

Rajat Gupta; Research Analyst; JPMorgan Chase & Co, Research Division

Presentation

Operator

Good afternoon, and welcome to the Penske Automotive Group Fourth Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Today's call is being recorded and will be available for replay approximately 1 hour after completion through February 14, 2024, on the company's website under the Investors tab at www.penskeautomotive.com.
I will now introduce Tony Pordon, the company's Executive Vice President of Investor Relations and Corporate Development. Sir, please go ahead.

Anthony R. Pordon

Thank you, Brad. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. As you know, a press release detailing Penske Automotive Group's fourth quarter 2023 financial results was issued this morning and is posted on our website, along with the presentation designed to assist you in understanding the company's results. As always, I'm available by e-mail or phone for any follow-up questions you may have.
Joining me for today's call are Roger Penske, our Chair and CEO; Shelley Hulgrave, our EVP and Chief Financial Officer; Rich Shearing, North American Operations; Randall Seymore, International Operations; and Tony Facione, our Vice President and Corporate Controller.
Our discussion today may include forward-looking statements about our operations, earnings potential, outlook, future events, growth plans, liquidity and assessment of business conditions. We may also discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures, such as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization or EBITDA, adjusted EBITDA and adjusted earnings before taxes, adjusted income from continuing operations, adjusted earnings per share and our leverage ratio. We have prominently presented the comparable GAAP measures and have reconciled the non-GAAP measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures in the press release and investor presentation, which are available on our website.
Our future results may vary from our expectation because of risks and uncertainties outlined in today's press release under forward-looking statements. I direct you to our SEC filings, including our Form 10-K and previously filed Form 10-Qs for additional discussion and factors that could cause future results to differ materially from expectations.
I'll now turn the call over to Roger.

Roger S. Penske

Tony, thank you, and good afternoon, everyone, and I appreciate everyone joining us today. 2023 was a strong year for PAG and reflected our third best year of net income in our company's history. Our performance is driven by a resilient new car market, our premium brand mix, the performance of our retail commercial truck dealerships and our capital allocation. During 2023, we delivered 486,000 new and used vehicles and over 21,000 commercial trucks. We increased our revenue 6% to almost $30 billion. We generated $1.4 billion in earnings before taxes and nearly $1.1 billion of net income and earnings per share of $15.50. We continue to grow our business announcing acquisitions of $1.3 billion and expected annualized revenue, including Rybrook in the U.K., which closed early in January 2024.
We repurchased 2.8 million shares or approximately 4% of the shares outstanding at the beginning of the year. We increased our cash dividend paid to shareholders by 53% since the end of 2022 and from $0.57 to our current dividend of $0.87. We maintained a strong balance sheet and debt to capitalization ratio of 26% and a leverage ratio of one time.
Now let's turn our attention to the fourth quarter that we announced earlier today excluding a noncash impairment charge as noted in our press release, adjusted EBT was just under $300 million at $297 million. Adjusted income from continuing operations was $231 million and related adjusted earnings per share was $3.45.
In our automotive operations, we believe demand for new vehicles remains solid and inventory availability continues to improve. We continue to take forward orders with pretty sold activity averaging between 10% and 20% in the U.S. depending on brand and the region. The U.K. forward order book is healthy at 20,300 units. Although the order book is slightly less than last year, U.K. new vehicle registrations increased 18% in 2023 and the availability of inventory improvement when compared to the same time last year.
During the quarter, total automotive units delivered increased 8% to 117,000 units, which includes 8,113 agency units. Same-store retail automotive revenue increased 4% including a 7% increase in our service and parts business. Same-store gross profit only declined 1%. Same-store retail commercial truck gross profit only declined 1% and earnings before taxes in Q4 was a record of over $51 million. Unfortunately, our profitability was impacted by $21 million in additional interest costs resulting from higher interest rates and greater inventory levels combined with lower equity earnings from our investment in Penske Transportation Solutions.
Turning to PTS, December 31, PTS managed a fleet of over 439,000 vehicles. That includes trucks, tractors and trailers. In 2023, PTS operating revenue increased 6% and produced the third highest EBT of all time, just over $1 billion. In Q4, PTS operating revenue increased 3% to $2.7 billion. Full service lease and contract revenue increased 13%. Logistics revenue increased 5%, but our rental business declined 13%. PTS generated $177 million in net income. Our share of PTS earnings was $51 million, which declined by 48% or $48 million compared to Q4 of last year.
Decline in PTS earnings over the year period was impacted by the following: a $57 million increase in interest expense from higher rates related to bond, refinancings and higher outstanding debt. A $58 million decline in gain on sale of used trucks when compared to the record performance. In 2022, as used truck values continued to be impacted by the lower freight demand. We sold nearly 36,000 trucks used in 2023, an increase of 60%. Rental revenue fell 13%, including 400 basis points decline in commercial utilization rates at 82%. Higher depreciation and holding costs on older vehicles, we had -- because we're holding to replace the fleet. As we look into Q1 2024, PTS continues to be impacted by similar headwinds. We expect PTS earnings to decline at least 50% in the first quarter due to higher interest costs, a lower gain on sale of used trucks and higher depreciation.
Units delivered now at 29,000 compared to 71,000 at the start of last year and continue to trend lower. We have nearly 18,000 units currently available for sale. In January, we sold 3,900 units, which was 27% higher than January 2023 and similar to the pace of Q4.
I'd now like to turn it over to Rich Shearing.

Richard P. Shearing

Thank you, Roger. Our Premier Truck Dealership business represents 34 locations in North America and is an important part of our diversification. We have one of the largest commercial truck retailers for Daimler Trucks North America. And as most of you may know, earlier last year, we expanded into the greater Winnipeg, Manitoba market area acquiring 5 new locations representing $180 million in estimated annualized revenue.
The North American Class 8 retail truck had a strong year in 2023 with a 7% increase in retail sales to 331,000 units. At the end of December, the backlog was $178,000, which compares to a backlog of 244,000 at the same time last year. The current backlog represents approximately a 5- to 6-month rate of retail sales.
In 2023, our business generated over 21,000 new and used truck sales, $3.7 billion in revenue and almost $600 million in gross profit, an improvement of 7% year-over-year. Premier Truck Group had a record year, generating $225 million in EBT and more than a 6% return on sale.
I'm pleased that the business produced a solid Q4, with EBT of $51 million, as Roger referenced, the record, despite new unit sales for the quarter being down 13% related to later-than-normal deliveries in 4Q 2022 due to supply chain disruptions earlier that year. On a same-store basis, gross margin increased to 140 basis points to 15.8% and SG&A to gross profit remained well controlled at 58.8%. Fixed absorption was solid at 123%. We believe commercial truck demand remains solid and will continue to drive -- be driven primarily by replacement demand and we see strength across private fleets and Class 6, 7 medium duty as well.
I would now like to turn the call over to Randall Seymore.

Randall Seymore

Thanks, Rich. 2023 was also a record year for our business in Australia. As you know, we are the exclusive importer and distributor of heavy -- certain heavy- and medium-duty trucks and buses and a leading distributor of engines and power systems in Australia and New Zealand. We offer products in the trucking, mining, power generation, defense, marine, rail and construction sectors and support full parts and aftersales service through a network of branches, field service locations and dealers across the region. In our Australia business, service and parts represents approximately 80% of all of our gross profit. So our focus on increasing units in operation is a key driver of the business.
In 2023, the Australia business grew its revenue by 10%, largely due to the off-highway markets, which remained strong, particularly in the data center, energy solutions and mining segments.
In the Energy Solutions space, we continue to lead the market in critical standby power, especially for data centers and made significant deliveries of generators into prime power and hybrid applications. In addition, we have started to deliver large-scale battery energy storage solution systems as well. Our current order bank for Energy Solution delivery stands at over $500 million for 2024 and beyond.
In mining, we continue to deliver repowers with the fuel-efficient MTU Series 4000 engines, and we're working with one of the world's largest miners to develop a hybrid repower solution, which will reduce fuel consumption by 20%.
I would now like to turn the call over to Shelley Hulgrave.

Michelle Hulgrave

Thank you, Randall. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm pleased to report that we generated $1.1 billion in cash flow last year and our EBITDA was nearly $1.7 billion. In 2023, we continue to maintain a disciplined and balanced approach to capital allocation and our balance sheet remains strong, safe and secure. At December 31, we had $96 million in cash, $529 million in vehicle equity and $1.7 billion in availability under our credit agreement. .
Our approach to capital allocation balances investing for growth through capital expenditures, diversified and opportunistic acquisitions, while also returning capital to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Since the end of 2022, we have raised the dividend 5x from $0.57 to $0.87 per share, representing a 53% increase. We returned $189 million in dividends to shareholders last year. We also repurchased 2.8 million shares for $382 million. Total inventory was $4.3 billion, representing an increase of $800 million from the end of 2022. Floor plan debt was $3.8 billion.
We had a 39-day supply of new vehicles and a 48-day supply of used. Days supply of new vehicles for premium was 42% and volume foreign was 24%. At December 31, our supply of battery electric vehicles in the U.S. was 54 days for new and 50 days for used. In the U.K., our supply of battery electric vehicles was 67 days for new and 45 days for used.
At the end of the summer, our long-term debt was $1.6 billion, essentially flat year-over-year. Approximately $1 billion of the long-term debt represents our subordinated notes with $550 million maturing in 2025 and the other $500 million maturing in 2029. The average interest rate on these notes is 3.6%. We also have $403 million in mortgages and $182 million in other borrowings at our international subsidiaries.
Debt to total capitalization improved to 26% from 28% at the end of 2022, and our leverage sits at one time. It's important to reiterate that we have the ability to flex our leverage up to 4x on a lease-adjusted basis. Therefore, we have room under our credit agreement to deploy our capital allocation strategies. Our U.S. credit agreement provides for up to $1.2 billion in revolving loans for working capital, acquisitions, capital expenditures, investments and other corporate purposes, and was fully available at the end of December.
SG&A to gross profit was 71% in the quarter and remains 700 basis points below the pre-pandemic level of 77.9% in 2019. We continue to focus our efforts on efficiencies and cost control. As part of our ongoing efforts, we continue to challenge our costs and focus on simplification, optimization and digitization to drive further efficiency and lower cost structure. In fact, our U.S. same-store head count remains down 11% when compared to pre-COVID head count levels.
Further, in our U.S. automotive operations, variable compensation to gross profit improved 30 basis points and service and parts absorption improved 120 basis points when compared to Q4 last year.
At this time, I will turn the call back to Roger for some final remarks.

Roger S. Penske

Thanks, Shelley. As Shelley mentioned, our balance sheet is strong, and we have the ability to flex our capital allocation opportunistically. We demonstrated that flexibility in January by expanding our brand footprint in the U.K. as we completed an acquisition of 16 premium brand dealerships, representing approximately $1 billion in estimated annual revenue. Our U.K. team is currently integrating these dealerships into our operations, and we are thrilled to add the Rybrook team to our business.
Lastly, I'm pleased to report that Penske Automotive Group was recently named as a Fortune World's Most Admired Company for 2024 and was recently honored by Glassdoor as the best place to work in 2024. Our results continue to demonstrate the benefit of our diversification across the retail automotive and commercial truck industries, our cost control and disciplined capital allocation strategy. I remain confident in our model and the performance of our business.
Again, thanks for joining us today, and we'll open the call up for questions. Thank you.

Question and Answer Session

Operator

(Operator Instructions) we can first go to John Murphy with Bank of America.

John Joseph Murphy

I just wanted to start, Roger, with a question on the state of play on EVs. And Shelley, I appreciate you giving us those inventory numbers, so they're helpful. I was just wondering if you could talk about sort of the pace of sales, the mood to consumers as they're buying or not buying these EVs, just the general environment with the automakers and what kind of capital requirements they're making you invest in, either from charging or facilities to support the sales.
Just trying to get your general view of the state of play here. And how much it actually matters to you if you might be able to offset that by selling hybrids in ICE vehicles if we are really stalled here on the EV front?

Roger S. Penske

Okay, John, let me take a shot and have Rich make a comment. But there's no question that demand for BEV has slowed. And when you look at our business, 51% of our BEV business is in California, and of that business, 90% is leased. So right now, the OEMs in order to push the business in the luxury side, at least, they're having to lease it and have residual risk.
We think the bridging strategy is certainly going to be is hybrid, and that's been proven with what China is committed to now going forward with (inaudible) at 100%. 7% of the market was BEV, obviously, last year. And when we look at our days supply, we're running at about 53 days as of the end of the year.
In the U.K., BEV units were really at that point, they were much higher at 36% of the market. The BEV days supply in the U.K. is 67. So when we step back and look at it right now in California, we can't even get chargers installed at our location because there's not power available just to -- obviously, to supply them. We see that not only on the retail car side, but also on the truck side. But those are a couple of comments from me. Rich, you want to follow up?

Richard P. Shearing

Yes, John, I think we're at an inflection point where early on, we had customers that were early adopters certainly went out, bought the BEV. Those early adopters now already have them and you're getting to the point where you're trying to convince the customer, find their first BEV or their last ICE.
And so going back to what Roger said about our overall BEV sales in the U.S. being in California, earlier this week talking to our management team there, we're starting to think that, that market is getting saturated. When you look across the balance of the country, certainly, the BEV adoption percentages are at much, much lower rate. And so we see that in our inventory starting to climb with BEV inventory in the U.S. just under 1,500 units, 12% of our total inventory. That's up 34% from the end of Q3, which is indicative of the sales rate starting to slow down a little bit.

John Joseph Murphy

That's very helpful. Just a second question on GPUs that have been holding in better than many people have feared and obviously, that goes along with pricing. Just curious if you can talk about sort of your expectations there for pricing and new GPUs. And maybe put that in the context of how negative weight the GPUs are on EVs relative to sort of your total?

Roger S. Penske

Tony, do you want to give some...

Anthony R. Pordon

Sure, Roger. John, thanks for the question. So when you take a look at how our gross looked at the overall business from Q4 to Q3, so when you look at the sequential side of things, we actually did quite well. New was down 257, used was down 123 and F&I was up on a total basis.
When you look at our overall business in total, we were selling somewhere around 40-ish percent of the cars at MSRP. So we're very happy with that and about 28% of the deals that we have right now are in cash. So when you look at the total variable gross profit that we generated on a sequential basis from Q3 to Q4, we were up in that $80, $90 range per unit. So we're very pleased with our overall performance on the gross profit side.

John Joseph Murphy

And Tony, just any color on how much of a weight the EVs are on that or where they're kind of landing for you on GPUs?

Anthony R. Pordon

Yes. So they're running somewhere in the neighborhood of $5,000 or so below MSRP.

Richard P. Shearing

So John, Tony said 41% or 40% of our cars last year at MSRP. If you look conversely at BEV, 83% of our BEV sales were below MSRP by more than $5,800. And if you look at just across all the brands we represent on a weighted average, the ICE GPPU is almost $2,200 less than a comparable ICE.

Roger S. Penske

The discount is of GPU.

Richard P. Shearing

Of GPU.

Roger S. Penske

And also, John, I would have to say that we have action on BEVs probably 60,000 and below. And when you start looking at inventory above 60, EQS, EQE 120, 115 days. Am I correct? Day supply. So there's no question and we're starting to see even in the U.K., that another 1% discount for us on those vehicles last year or last month. Do you have any comment on it at all from internationally?

Randall Seymore

Yes. In the U.K., BEV was flat year-over-year. In fact, it was down 10 basis points. And looking at January, it was down another 180 basis points from a market share standpoint. So look at it, it's a little bit different there because there's -- the retail BEVs would be de minimis. Meanwhile, it's all through corporate fleet programs because of the tax break.
So it's a little bit apples to oranges. And then you look at other parts of Europe, like Italy and Spain, it's 4% market share because there's no government incentive. So Germany, the government incentives finished at the end of the year. So it's going to be interesting to see what happens there without this intervention by the government.

Operator

Next, we go to Mike Ward with Freedom Capital.

Michael Ward

Starting on CarShop. It wasn't long ago that everybody wanted CarShop to spin off and go a separate, probably, entity. And we've had major disruption in the market over the last few years. Does that change how you look at it structurally, how big is the advantage being part of PAG?
Is it just part of the portfolio? And with this reset or this adjustment -- tax adjustment in the U.K., is this a chance to accelerate on the pedal? Or is it just reconfiguring in or change in the strategy? How are you looking at it?

Michelle Hulgrave

Mike, it's Shelley. I'll take that question. We had mentioned in our press release that we had an impairment related to our CarShop U.K. question or our CarShop U.K. business. And when you dig into the details and you try to establish the fair value, it became very clear that though we initially looked at these businesses separate from the franchise dealerships, if you will, there are so many synergies that we've put in place over time.
We've moved systems. We've incorporated a lot of the same franchise, F&I products and the like. So I think there's a great benefit to looking at the CarShop businesses consistent with the franchise stores. There's also a lot of sourcing opportunities and similarities there. So buying off the curve, if you will, purchasing cars from customers directly that's had a huge benefit to us as well.
So I think there's a lot of benefit. Certainly, those that have spun off have not always succeeded as we've seen this year. And as we look forward to the future and looked at this from a calculation standpoint, our focus isn't so much on what the used car market is doing right now, but really what's available from a new -- our perspective. As you see the SAAR growing, we expect to see a similar used car SAAR, if you will, grow as well and have more affordable cars available for our CarShop locations.

Michael Ward

So as we look forward, then it becomes more of a partnership with the retail automotive?

Michelle Hulgrave

I think it's been for a long time, Mike.

Roger S. Penske

But even more so, I think just charge, obviously, technically when they look at it and Shelley's team along with the auditors look at this. So it wasn't something that we didn't expect. And obviously, we reduced 2 locations in the U.S. this year, which had been losing money, and we have been able to sell one location and one will move over to PTS from the standpoint from a leasing and rental location.
But as far as the U.K. is concerned, we think it's a valued brand. And as we go forward, we'll continue to operate it. I think we had, what? $150 million value, and we took 27% as a goodwill impairment on that. So look, it's part of doing business but I'm so glad that we didn't listen to people among spinning it off, let me say that.

Michael Ward

Myself included. On PTS, one of the things you try to do is the last couple of years, again, have been highly unusual, but when you look at the growth path, particularly if you go back to 2019, 2018 and those sorts of things, there are a lot of positive changes. So even if we're down again in 2024, some of the disruption we've seen in the last 2 to 3 quarters are more market related? And is there anything that stops this company from once we get through 2024, getting back onto a growth phase?

Roger S. Penske

Not at all. And when you look at it right now, I think we mentioned it earlier, our lease business was up 21%. And our logistics business up 5%. Unfortunately, we've grown our rental fleet to almost 90,000 units. And of course, as the market slowed spot rates came down, our utilization went down from 88% down to roughly 82%. And I think that gave us an excess supply. On top of that, a lot of those pieces are being used to support leases that we had written when we were at 70,000 units on order and couldn't get them from the manufacturers. We were using some rental units. So those who will now come back as we've seen the supply start to come in.
Our issue is we have approximately 18,000 -- 16,000 to 18,000 units for sale and to get those out, that's about 8,000 more than we had a year ago. We're paying depreciation, interest and maintenance on those as they sit. So we'll have to pull that stuff through. And I would say that impact will continue through the first quarter. So I would say we'd be similar as far as value and actually earnings in the first quarter, similar to what we had in Q4.
Based on lower rental volume, both and on the consumer side, which is our one-way business, there's less people moving because of house prices and when they do move, it looks like the mileage is down. So that's really hit us. And then we had -- the company had $213 million, I think roughly of total interest cost increase in 2023, $100 million of that based on new debt and $100 million on refinance. So gain on sale, financing, lower revenue and rental really impacted us. But from an energy standpoint, meaning from an offense in sales, we were up in our core products.

Anthony R. Pordon

Mike, I want to add to that, that when you look at Q4 we actually saw the year-over-year change in maintenance. It became more favorable to us. So maintenance at (inaudible) down $11 million in the fourth quarter when you compare it to the prior year. So that means this process is working, taking the trucks out of the fleet is working. So we hope that, that continues into the future.

Roger S. Penske

With the extension, Mike, of some 28,000 older units that we had to extend from, say, 6 to 12 months, those such thing, each up on maintenance, number one. And number two, we don't get any margin on that extension revenue. So that had a double impact on us.

Operator

And next, we can go to Daniel Imbro with Stephens Inc.

Daniel Robert Imbro

Roger, maybe I want to expand a little bit on the last topic. I think we started with CarShop there. Maybe just to expand to the broader used business on the franchise side. Can you talk about the headwinds on that business that are weighing on same-store units kind of close to flat this quarter?
It seems like obviously, there's demand headwinds, but you guys having historically high lease penetration. Are we starting to see more supply issues, maybe lack of lease returns coming back? I'm just curious, as you look at those headwinds, how that plays out through 2024.

Roger S. Penske

Well, look, number one, we know the market stabilize because as we look at our wholesale units, both in the U.K. and the U.S., we were profitable in Q4. That's point number 1 and point number 2. I think availability, one of the things that's impacted us is getting the right car to right price. It really is CarShop. We were looking in the U.S., it's somewhere between say, 19,000 and 22,000. Well, those cars that we could get were almost 10,000 more from the standpoint of being able to get them to purchase and then sell them. Same thing in the U.K.
Well, I think what's going on now is we're starting to see those numbers come down. I guess, you say deflation on used vehicles in the U.K. But more importantly, with leasing being down to somewhat 25% in the past 2 years and we haven't had, obviously, the lease returns have not come back and probably even more important is in the premium side, I think we have, what, Shelley, 6,000 or 7,000 loaner cars in the premium side?

Michelle Hulgrave

That's right.

Roger S. Penske

I can't give you exact number. We were turning those units anywhere from 60 to 90 to 120 days, and those are great used car units. We really didn't have those because I can tell you in our big BMW store and at Crevier in California, they're running used cars almost 12 months. So we didn't have the ability to take them out, and those would become really prime used cars. So that's going to help us as we go forward and certainly overall, it gives us a chance to have more units, 7,200 units maybe more than we could sell that we put through the system, which is key for us.
Rich, any other comment you have?

Richard P. Shearing

No, I think the availability -- you mentioned demand versus availability. And I think the demand is still there. It is just the availability of cars with the new car SAAR being down, cumulatively almost 9.5 million in the last 4 years. The best source for used cars as new car purchasers on trade, and that just hasn't been there. You combine that with the low lease rates that Roger mentioned. It certainly has been a challenge. And then I think we've been more disciplined as well to make sure that we're not buying cars in segment 2, segment 3, just to keep sales rates up because you end up with customer service issues and policy goodwill expense.

Daniel Robert Imbro

That's all helpful color. Maybe if I could follow up on the commercial truck side of the house. Obviously, a strong full year result. But if I look at 4Q, parts and service maybe slowed a little bit more than we thought it would, Roger has stated lighter. Can you just maybe talk through the puts and takes of what is going on there, maybe some of it is the wholesale part side? And then same question, kind of how that plays out through 2024 and 2025 as you guys see the market developing?

Roger S. Penske

Yes, I'll let Rich answer that one directly.

Richard P. Shearing

Yes, Daniel, you're definitely right. We did see a slowdown in the second half of last year. Obviously, the freight was very robust. Utilization of assets was very high. You had a lot of owner-operator single truck operators coming into the market to take advantage of those rates because they can make substantial money. They generally were getting their truck service with independent repair centers, and that creates big parts revenue and profit opportunities for us.
So we've seen a decline in our wholesale parts sales and then just our general retail traffic of parts sales over the counter. You look at our service shops, we're still busy. We don't have the backlog of service work that we had previously, but we're still steady with the number of ROs that we're generating on a monthly basis. And then because of the freight decline and the asset utilization down, you've got some carriers that would park trucks and maybe pull another truck from the fence versus having the expense of repairing it. So we're seeing some of that as well until some of that capacity tightens in the marketplace.

Roger S. Penske

I think, Rich, also, when you look at our fixed coverage, we're running, what, 120-plus percent.

Richard P. Shearing

Yes, almost 130.

Roger S. Penske

And I think we're utilizing tools to be more efficient. We've also been able to fill a lot of the mechanics requirements that we couldn't get during the COVID time. We're now seeing them come in and our turnover really has been down. So I would say we've put more service trucks on the road going out to the customers, too, which has certainly also been a benefit. So I think through our acquisitions that we'll see that we'll start to get some more traction there to putting in some of the same conditions and action plans we have in the core business.

Operator

(Operator Instructions) We'll go next to Rajat Gupta with JPMorgan.

Rajat Gupta

Just had one question on new GPUs and then one on F&I. Based on how things have trended over the last few months and quarters including what you may have seen in January? Is the recent quarterly cadence, like roughly $250 to $300 of sequential declines in new GPU, a good rule of thumb? Or as you progress through 2024, if you could give us any color or guidance around that would be helpful. And I have a quick follow-up on F&I.

Anthony R. Pordon

So Rajat, this is Tony. I'll handle that one. When you take a look at the year-over-year decline from Q4 '22 to Q4 '23, new gross was down about $956 a car. That's on a same-store basis across the portfolio. And I think, as I previously mentioned, when we looked at it sequentially, it was down $257 from $57.75 down to $55.18. So I think we're able to manage the growth very well. Some of it will be dependent upon how the mix might change from one period to the next and the level of BEV sales. I think Rich made the comment that we were down over $5,000 versus MSRP on the BEV side of things.
So I think we're very happy with how the new vehicle growth has performed so far in the past 12 months.

Roger S. Penske

I'd make one comment, Rajat, that we're seeing internationally Ferrari and Porsche, Lamborghini, some of those big cars are now in the $200,000, $300,000 range, people could drive them for a year and come back and trade them to be able to get into the next car. We're seeing some people are saying, look, I'll keep my car for another year. So that's having some impact on canceled orders where we have to resell those at a lower margin. But I wouldn't say it's dramatic, but I think it's something we should note because of the used vehicle decline.

Anthony R. Pordon

That happened in the fourth quarter.

Roger S. Penske

In the fourth quarter, yes.

Rajat Gupta

Got it. That's helpful. And then on F&I, a very strong performance here in the fourth quarter, despite what we're hearing that leasing is coming back. We can see that the data -- what drove the strength there? And how should we think about sustaining these kind of F&I gross levels into 2024?

Anthony R. Pordon

Well, Rajat, this is Tony. If you look at the fourth quarter on a same-store basis, we did 18.97 a unit. That was up from 18.66 and then sequentially, it was up about $76 a unit from 18.21 to 18.97. I think it's important to point out that when you look at the U.S. our overall product sales are about 68% of the total.
Therefore, reserves are about 32%. And then you look at some of the different penetration rates. We've increased our captive penetration again leasing is up a little bit. And then when you look at some of the different programs that we're selling, like prepaid maintenance and protection products, tire and wheel, that stuff has stayed really strong for us.
So I think overall, our team is doing a really strong job on the F&I side of things.

Roger S. Penske

And those are products that we can sell to the premium lease customer too, which is helpful.

Rajat Gupta

Got it. So you feel okay about sustaining these kind of levels on a same-store basis. Obviously, like pricing might play a role there, but the penetration level, do you think are sustainable at these levels into '24?

Anthony R. Pordon

Some of it will depend upon the absolute lease level that we have, particularly in the U.S. and then we also have to look at any potential affordability concerns that customers may have with respect to extended service contracts. But I think if you look at the second half of the year and you see any rate reduction that might happen in interest rates, so that could actually help the F&I side of the business as well, making vehicles more affordable.

Roger S. Penske

But it's only 32% of our revenue is coming from the actual reserves.

Anthony R. Pordon

Correct.

Roger S. Penske

And flat we would get on leasing.

Operator

Next, we'll go to David Whiston with Morningstar.

David Whiston

Two questions like kind of the capital allocation front. First on M&A, can you say what your preference would be this year on M&A in terms of would it be light vehicle, CarShop or trucks? And on top of that, what geographic areas would be your first choice?

Roger S. Penske

Well, I guess, let's look at the different businesses. We are actively looking in Premier Truck side. There's no question in Europe. We had the opportunity with Rybrook 16 locations. We have a number of opportunities here in the U.S. And I would say we look primarily where we already have scale. .
So we can consolidate our back offices, our management team with Rybrook, we looked at the business at Pendragon and when we looked at that business in conjunction, we had a set of losses we'd have to deal with, with Rybrook. We just bought the stores and plugged them right in. So we want to look where we have the least amount of additional SG&A that would be a key factor.
And I think right now, we're seeing the prices coming down to a more realistic time frame. And obviously, with $1.7 billion of capital available, we've got plenty of fire proper to make a big move or small moves. But again, they're going to be strategic.

David Whiston

But you don't have a strong preference then on truck versus light vehicle, that doesn't really matter?

Roger S. Penske

I think we look at them one at a time. I mean, we're -- it's not -- we don't have a goal to grow the truck at some speed or else. I want to see a minimum of $1 billion worth of new business that we would generate for 2024 on an annualized basis, that would be across the entire portfolio.

David Whiston

Okay. And on buybacks, can you talk about how you guys are feeling about buybacks this year relative to the 2023 spending level?

Roger S. Penske

Well, look, I think as we've done before, we look at CapEx, we look at dividends, we look at acquisitions, we look at buybacks. And I think that we certainly will look at that to continue. The Board has to approve those buybacks and make recommendations to us. But at this point, we would continue with our buybacks.

David Whiston

And just one last thing on used vehicles. In the press release you guys specifically called out that how pleased you were on that sequential GPU performance Q4 versus Q3. Is it kind of -- for lack of better words, is that like a green shoot that may be the worst of this is over?

Anthony R. Pordon

Are you talking on used vehicles, David?

David Whiston

Yes.

Anthony R. Pordon

So Randall will tell you, Randy, you might want to comment about what we're seeing in the U.K. because that was one of the big headwinds, if you will, so you want...

Randall Seymore

So as all the valuations went significantly up over '21, '22. And then obviously, starting April last year, they were going down anywhere from 2% to 4% a month. In the fourth quarter, it was down 4%, 4% and 2% from October, November, December. So look, it was a challenge without a doubt, you had to turn the inventory quickly. Otherwise, you're caught with that at a lower number, you can sell it.
But as we've come into the new year in January, it's absolutely stabilized, and we're seeing that in February as well. Our gross per unit will definitely be up in January for the first handful of trading days in February, the same thing. I'll make one other point. When we are rightsizing the inventory, we wholesale 10,000 cars, but our wholesale -- we actually made about GBP 370 per unit, which was down from GBP 400 per unit Q4 last year. So it wasn't down much. If you think about the market going down that in the way it did.
So there certainly wasn't a fire sale. But conversely to that, we in late November and December went out and acquired a bunch of used cars strategically as the market was deflated and now as the markets stabilized and hopefully goes up some, that's part of the reason we're seeing better grosses this month. So I think we were a bit advantageous there with our team.

Roger S. Penske

Well, look, I think then the key thing, David, is that we were paying money for used cars. It was almost, in some cases, near where they could buy a new car for. So the amount of gross profit that was available to us from an advance rate from the finance company. Remember, we financed a lot of the used cars, left us a very small margin as the cost of sale comes down now, it's going to give us a chance now we've got interest rates pushing that up on a finance deal.
But I think we're going to see our margins will increase as we go forward. And I feel good about the used car business, be able to turn the loaner cars, all these things are going to help us as we go forward, especially on the premium side. And hopefully, we'll start to get some lease returns, you talked about advantageous buying 250 cars from Mercedes, I think in last year in the fourth quarter. So these things will start to help us that we can execute on.

Anthony R. Pordon

And our average transaction price last year was over $34,000 a used car, that's high.

David Whiston

What was the year before?

Anthony R. Pordon

It was flat on a year-over-year basis roughly. So it really when you go back, I think, to 2019 prior to the pandemic, it was $25,000...

Roger S. Penske

The CarShop number is coming down. We can see the sale price of CarShop. So, I'm not sure exactly what it is, but I know it's coming down and that's going to help us get back in the sweet spot.

Michelle Hulgrave

That's right.

Roger S. Penske

So we're not competing with what I call the OEM dealership, right, because it will be down and it's a different market that we have.

David Whiston

Sorry, was that 34,000 a CarShop or the retail stores?

Anthony R. Pordon

That's total consolidated number that's everybody -- if you look at CarShop, the average transaction price was just under $21,000 in the fourth quarter. .

Operator

With no further questions in queue, I'd like to turn the call back over to Mr. Penske for closing remarks.

Roger S. Penske

Brad, thanks. Good quarter, we had some headwind, obviously, but I feel good about the balance of the year. Obviously, we talked about battery electric vehicle. That's got a big focus on us and how we deal with that as we go forward here. So thanks again. We'll talk to you next quarter.

Operator

That does conclude the call for today. Thanks for your participation. You may now disconnect.