UK markets close in 46 minutes

StockBeat: Wirecard's Mini-Bounce Shows Trust Slow to Return

By Geoffrey Smith -- German payments company Wirecard enjoyed only a mini-bounce in confidence on Monday after replacing its chairman, suggesting it still has plenty of work to do to regain investor trust after allegations about its accounting practices.

Shares in the company recovered only 1.9% to 112.83 euros by 5:15 AM ET (10:15 GMT), in response to an announcement on Friday that long-serving chairman Wulf Matthias will step down with immediate effect “for personal reasons”. He’ll be replaced by Thomas Eichelmann, who joined the supervisory board as an independent director midway through last year. Matthias will continue to serve on the board until his contract expires next year.

The move suggests that management is belatedly taking a more constructive approach to addressing concerns about its historic accounting practices, which have been attacked in a series of disclosures by the Financial Times over the last two years. The FT’s findings suggest the company used various tactics to inflate its sales and profits – suggestions that the company denies.

Wirecard ultimately commissioned an independent review into its accounting by KPMG in October, only days after Matthias had said that such a step was unnecessary. The FT reported that Eichelmann had been instrumental in securing an independent review.

The outcome of the KPMG review is likely to have a big impact on the company’s shares. Wirecard was a darling of retail investors during the period of its fastest growth, and its inclusion in the benchmark DAX index made it a must-hold for thousands of institutional accounts. However, investor confidence in the company has been shaken not just by the allegations themselves, but also by the company’s apparent recalcitrance in addressing them.

Wirecard repeatedly accused the FT of being in league with short-sellers, who have increasingly targeted the stock. Some 6.5% of the company’s free float stock was sold short as of the end of last year, according to data compiled by

The shares are currently 41% below their all-time high, posted in September 2018, when its market capitalization briefly exceeded that of Deutsche Bank (DE:DBKGn). However, the shares still look expensive by some metrics, with its market value at over 5.6 times the last 12 months’ revenue and its enterprise value 15 times the management’s forecast for next year’s EBITDA.

Wirecard was the best-performing stock in the DAX on Monday on a day still overshadowed by the weak U.S. labor market report on Friday. The benchmark Euro Stoxx 600 was up 0.1% at 419.48, while the FTSE 100 was up 0.5%, thanks largely to hopes of a rate cut from the Bank of England, which weighed on sterling.

Related Articles

India stocks higher at close of trade; Nifty 50 up 0.59%

Stocks - Europe Opens Higher as Macro Backdrop Improves

Stocks Push Higher; Yuan Strengthens: Markets Wrap