Jennifer Garner/Instagram Jennifer Garner
Jennifer Garner just introduced us all to our new favorite condiment.
On Monday, the actress posted a fun video from her kitchen as part of her "Pretend Cooking Show" on Instagram that showed her throwing together "the most obvious staple I'd never made": maple butter.
Consisting of just a stick of butter and 1 cup of maple syrup, the easy recipe still hilariously trips up Garner, 49. "Oops, I did that backwards," she tells the camera while realizing she heated the ingredients in the wrong order.
But as it turns out, "You can do the butter first or you can heat the maple syrup first. Either way, you're gonna whisk 'em together. It doesn't matter!" the Yes Day star says.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.
Instagram Ina Garten's comment on Jennifer Garner's video
At the end of the clip, Garner debates what to put her sweet new spread on, settling on a slice of bread — and it seems she made the right decision.
"Lord, yes," she says blissfully after taking a bite.
The actress even earned praise from celebrity-chef friend Ina Garten, who joked in a comment, "Love a recipe with two ingredients, one of which is buddah!! ❤️❤️❤️ 🧈."
RELATED VIDEO: Jennifer Garner on Parenting During the Pandemic and Why She Won't Have a Cooking Show Anytime Soon
Separately, they've each been sharing recipes with their followers all throughout quarantine. Garten's dishes have included everything from practical meals using affordable pantry staples like beans, lentils and ramen noodles to a giant cosmopolitan cocktail (made with 2 cups of vodka!) that hilariously tapped into the nationwide mood.
The Love, Simon actress also showed off the other recipes she'd made from Garten's book so far: milk-chocolate Oreo ice cream and frozen palomas. "My freezer will never be without one again!" Garner joked of the tequila-based cocktail.